Part 4
[[AD]]
Does that excuse James? No. But it does complicate the victim narrative. Because if Tiana was lying about something as fundamental as her own children, what else was she lying about? And more importantly, why should James be the only one held accountable?
The Editing Room Isn’t a Courtroom
Here’s something Catfish fans don’t talk about enough: the show’s editing is not neutral. It never has been. From the early seasons with Nev Schulman and Max Joseph to the later seasons with Kamie Crawford, the producers have a clear formula. The person who cooperates with the hosts gets the sympathetic edit. The person who doesn’t gets the villain edit.
Tiana cooperated. She sat down with Nev and Max. She cried. She explained. She gave them the emotional beats they needed for a compelling episode. James? He didn’t. He was evasive, defensive, and ultimately exposed as a liar. So of course the edit favors Tiana. That’s not justice. That’s television.
Think about other reality shows that play with perspective. The Jinx (2015, dir. Andrew Jarecki, 6 episodes, HBO) made Robert Durst look like a quirky old man before turning the screws. Making a Murderer (2015, dir. Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos, 10 episodes, Netflix) had viewers ready to riot for Steven Avery. But later seasons complicated that narrative. Catfish is no different. It’s designed to make you feel something. But feelings aren’t facts.
So when we say Tiana is the victim, we’re partly responding to a narrative that was constructed in the editing room. That doesn’t mean Tiana is a monster. It means she’s a person who made choices. And some of those choices were just as damaging as James’s.
Moral Equivalence Isn’t Innocence
Let’s be clear about what we’re not saying. We’re not saying Tiana deserved to be ghosted. We’re not saying James was the real victim. We’re not saying Tiana’s lies cancel out James’s lies. That’s not how morality works. It’s not a ledger where you tally up sins and whoever has fewer wins.
What we are saying is that Tiana had multiple chances to come clean. She could have told James about her kids before moving states. She could have told him when he expressed interest in being a dad to Journey. She could have told him when they talked about moving in together. But she didn’t. She waited until the cameras were rolling. And that’s a choice.
James, meanwhile, was hiding something too. We don’t know exactly what yet — the transcript hints at a baby mama and possibly more. But the point is, both of them were performing. Both of them were curating a version of themselves. And both of them got caught.
This is what makes Catfish so compelling after all these years. It’s not about saints and sinners. It’s about people who lie to themselves and each other. Tiana was both. James was both. And the show, for all its manipulation, captures that messy reality better than almost anything else on TV.
The Takeaway: Nobody’s Clean
So here’s where I land. If you still think Tiana is the victim, I respect it. You’ve got a case. James lied for three years. He refused to meet. He may have been hiding even more than we know. That’s real. That’s painful. And Tiana deserved better than that.
But Tiana also lied. She hid four kids. She knew James didn’t like kids. She moved states without telling him the truth. And she only came clean when the cameras showed up. That’s not victim behavior. That’s survival behavior. And survival behavior isn’t always pretty.
The strongest counter-argument to my whole thesis is this: maybe James was still worse. Maybe his lies were bigger. Maybe his deception was crueler. Maybe he was the real catfish all along. And you know what? Maybe you’re right. But that doesn’t make Tiana innocent. It just makes her human.
Catfish isn’t a courtroom. It’s a mirror. And what we see in Tiana is a reflection of our own capacity to lie, to hide, and to hope. She’s not a villain. She’s not a hero. She’s a person. And that’s the most complicated thing you can be.
Next time: what happened when Tiana and Trez reconnected — and why that fizzled too. Trust me, it’s worth the wait.
